Positive Thinking? Aye Right!


Recently, someone asked me how I was doing and I responded: absolutely fine for someone with no man, career, health and in the process of an enforced sale of my home. What’s more I meant it. Because how you’re feeling can be down to your attitude of mind, how you choose to think about your situation.

This reminded me of an exchange I had had on Twitter where I had argued against the proposition that there is power in positive thinking. So, have I just contradicted my argument? Let me explore this a little further.

Thinking happens both automatically and purposely. There is a whole spectrum of thinking–negative, catastrophic, positive, realistic, optimistic, dreaming, imagining and so on. Thinking influences the way we behave, the emotions we have and how we interact with ourselves and others. Can choosing to think in a particular way influence our health, particularly our physical health?

A part of the self-help industry, built on extolling the virtues of positive thinking, would have us believe so. In one book I read it suggested that if you repeat a positive affirmation for long enough it will become true. I picked one and tried it. It was : I am strong, I am healthy, I am powerful, relax I can manage. It was a lie. I knew it was a lie, my body knew it was a lie, my mind knew it was a lie. It was false positive thinking. It didn’t have a miraculous restorative effect on my physical health. There was no power in this type of positive thinking, for me at any rate.

Then I read Danea Horn’s book Chronic Resilience in which she posited a new approach called Honest Thinking which suggests that, rather than forcing yourself to be positive, or becoming stuck in permanent negativity, you should think honestly by recognising what is true at that moment.

This resonated with me. My mind will create negative thoughts for me based on age old stories I’ve told myself. Let’s take an example: ‘I’ll never be well again’. When that thought arises unbidden I first have to notice that it’s there in among all the other chatter going on. This involves mindfulness, a subject I’ve been studying for a while. Then I have to ask myself: ‘Is that true? Is that helpful?’

For me, no it’s not true or helpful because I do not know what my prognosis is. From there, I work at replacing that thought with one that is closer to the truth. To do this involves a conversation with myself that starts with self-compassion for feeling the way that produced the thought, then moving towards an honest assessment of the moment. For me that is: I am unwell just now, I want to be well and I commit to being open to any approaches that will bring me the health I seek. Then I have to go on and take the action that supports my thinking. This has a beneficial effect on my physical health.

When you go through this process with other negative thoughts, ultimately your outlook will become more realistic, neither negative nor pretendy positive. And it allows for imaginative and creative thinking, freeing yourself from outmoded patterns.

I think, however, there is a further step that is open to us and that is to actively look for the good in any situation in which you find yourself. In my case, I’m retiring at the end of this month because of my poor health. It is not a choice I would otherwise have made but it is now my reality. I have felt the loss of my career and I daresay I will do so again but, for now, I’m choosing purposely to see and think about the good in my situation: principally, I now have time and space in which to heal, lots of which I spend with my children, being the best mum I can be.

And I believe you can go even further than this: to pay attention to, appreciate and think about just how remarkable and wonderful our world is. My last post A Picture from Polmont was about just that. Then feel grateful for all the gifts you have. I see this in action every day. The most inspirational people are often in hellish predicaments choosing gratitude over resentment, appreciation over envy, love over hatred. Too many to mention but you know who you are and I’m in your debt.

So, think freely, think honestly, think widely, think with imagination, appreciation and gratitude and you will think healthily.

This is what I think. What do you think?


6 thoughts on “Positive Thinking? Aye Right!

  1. True thinking can be healthy – as you say ‘I am not well at the moment’ is better than ‘I will never be well again’ or ‘I can positive-think myself into being well’. Acceptance of reality is important for the chronically ill, but there is no need to add mental suffering to physical suffering that (depending on your illness) you can do nothing about.

  2. I love this and whole heartedly agree that nothing will come of being ‘ pretendy positive’ or negative but there can be huge benefits to assessing reality and looking for the positives. This really struck a chord with me as I just wrote a post with a very similar message! Hope you’re as well as can be and the sun is shining where you are 🙂

    • Thank you very kindly indeed. I must go and look at your blog now, will be really interested to read your posts. Yip, the sun is peeking out here, just a wee bit cold and windy to venture out!

      kind regards


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s